Review Article

Review of Life-Cycle Approaches Coupled with Data Envelopment Analysis: Launching the CFP + DEA Method for Energy Policy Making

Table 1

List of case studies currently available in the literature using LC + DEA methods.

ReferenceClassificationLC + DEA methodCase studyKey aspects

[38]Environmental3-step LCA + DEAElectronic devicesComparative ecoefficiency analysis
Ecopoint LCA scores used as inputs in the DEA matrix

[29]Environmental5-step LCA + DEAMussel raftsDirect link between operational and environmental efficiency
Lower economic expenses and lower environmental impacts

[26]Environmental3-step LCA + DEATrawling vessels in Galicia (NW Spain)Presentation of the 5-step LCA + DEA method
Inclusion of discards as bad output in DEA model

[31]Environmental3-step LCA + DEAMussel raftsJoint reduction targets computed for operational inputs and environmental impacts

[32]Environmental5-step LCA + DEADairy farms in Galicia (NW Spain)Benchmarking of environmental impacts
Superefficiency calculation for best-performing farms

[39]Environmental3-step LCA + DEAElectric and electronic productsDamage indicators provided by Ecoindicator 99 are included as inputs in the DEA matrix

[40]Environmental3-step LCA + DEAMahón cheese production (Balearic Islands, Spain)Analysis of most ecoefficient production techniques
Monte Carlo simulations to detect changes in the ecoefficiency ratio due to price fluctuations

[36]Environmental5 -step LCA + DEAGalician fishing fleets divided by gear type and fishing zoneIntra- and interassessment of fishing fleets
Operational inputs with low environmental contributions may still imply important economic savings if minimised

[33]Environmental5 -step LCA + DEAViticulture in the Rías Baixas appellation
(Galicia, Spain)
5-step LCA + DEA method including superefficiency analysis to identify best-performers
Environmental impacts include USEtox and CML impact categories

[41]Environmental3-step LCA + DEAEcoefficiency of construction materialsDEA is used to rank material alternatives, while LCA is used to quantify the environmental impacts

[42]Environmental3-step LCA + DEASwiss dairy farms in the Alpine areaDEA matrix made up of environmental impacts as inputs exclusively
Description of the relationship between economic and environmental performance

[45]EnvironmentalEIO-LCA + DEAUS manufacturing sectorHierarchical EIO-LCA + DEA method
Food, beverages, tobacco, and petroleum identified as drivers of overall environmental impact

[34]Environmental5-step LCA + DEASoybean farms in IranIdentification of bad operational practices and recommendation of improvement actions

[27]Environmental5-step LCA + DEA25 wind farms located in southern SpainEnvironmental benchmarks for end-of-life applications

[30]Environmental5-step LCA + DEAGalician fishing fleetsSocial indicators (e.g., working hours or crew size) included as inputs in LCA + DEA
Discussion of the advantages and drawbacks of these inclusions

[28]EnergyEm + DEA25 wind farms located in southern SpainEnergy-based ecoefficiency methods
Em + DEA viewed as an ecocentric perspective rather than an anthropogenic approach represented by CED and CExD
EnergyCED + DEA
EnergyCExD + DEA

[37]Environmental5-step LCA + DEAPeruvian anchoveta fishing fleet segmentsFishing fleet segments as DMUs rather than individual vessels
Clustering of LCI items as inputs in the DEA matrix

[35]Environmental5-step LCA + DEARice paddy fieldsDistinction between spring/summer rice paddy
Superefficiency analysis to identify best-performing entities